Skip to Content

NiftyThrifty Mystery Boxes – Yea or Nay?

I heard about NiftyThrifty through a friend a few months ago. It’s an online vintage store for affordable, secondhand clothing. They don’t have a storefront. However, they have a wide selection of dresses, shirts, and anything else you can imagine.

They often advertise their mystery boxes. They offer different deals with neckties, t-shirts, Hawaiian shirts, flannel, and scarves. I decided to try it. I ordered one mystery flannel, one mystery scarf,  and two mystery tees. With a coupon code, it costs around twenty dollars. Here’s what came in the mail.

image3 (1)

image2 (2)

image1 (5)

My thoughts? The flannel is fantastic. I ordered two sizes bigger on purpose. I now wear it all the time to stay warm during the winter. The scarf is pretty and colorful, but I haven’t worn it yet because I don’t know what to wear it with. I’m not a huge fan of the t-shirts, and I definitely won’t be wearing this Cookie monster one. My overall review? I give NiftyThrifty mystery boxes 4 stars.

Have you shopped on NiftyThrifty before? Have you ever bought a mystery box? What’s your favorite secondhand clothing store? Tweet @decorcione with your responses!